Sunday, 12 November 2023

A chimp typing the complete works of William Shakespeare

 


Someone on twitter/X asked the following question:

A mathematician emerges from a cave, hands you the photo below, and asks "Will a chimp type the complete works of William Shakespeare if the chimp hits keys at random on a typewriter for an infinite amount of time?" What is your answer?

I have no idea why this is so controversial with people arguing with each other. Someone banging on about infinite number of infinite sets and all sorts of baloney. And then answering no! Eh?? The answer is obviously yes.

People seem to think the chimp could avoid certain letters forever. That it would be possible for the chimp to, say, type out an infinite number of "A"s. It isn't. Nor any other specific infinite series. Any such specific infinite series (e.g. an infinite number of A's), would have a probability of 1/infinity of occurring. Which is 0.

All finite strings will not only eventually occur, each and every one of them also occurs an infinite number of times!

Incidentally, I haven't read anything up about this. It's just me thinking about it for 5 mins.

Saturday, 4 November 2023

The Bizarre beliefs of Philosophers and Scientists

Many philosophers and scientists have some truly bizarre beliefs. The denial of consciousness (as we understand this term) is the most bizarre. Indeed, I don't really understand what the consciousness deniers are really saying. That they literally never have any conscious experiences? No visual experiences, no thoughts, no pains, no yearnings etc? And if they don't mean this, what do they mean? It's worse than saying an experience is literally identical to a series of neurons firing... although that is utterly bizarre enough.


And I think stuff like the denial of mental causation; that there is no persisting self (not even from one minute to the next); that colours, sounds and smells don't exist out there; that there are ultimately only subatomic particles and their interactions that make up absolutely everything... I think all that is utterly bizarre too, although not quite reaching the absurdity of denying one's own conscious experiences.

But suppose I'm wrong about everything, that reality is really like what some of these people believe. Well.. I don't think I can possibly be wrong about my own consciousness, but what if I am wrong about everything else? Well . .if I am, then I am. I have tried to understand and grasp things, it's the best I can do.

But I do try to understand where people are coming from. Why on earth do they believe the bizarre things they do? It seems clear to me that it is our modern western culture that is the source of all these bizarre beliefs. There seems to be this infatuation with physics and a misinterpretation of what it's telling us.

To be honest, I think it's all largely groupthink. I think to a large extent they are just repeating each other, maybe they're concerned about their reputations and careers to want to rock the boat too much. And when others are continually expressing a certain view of the world, that surely has a powerful effect on one's own beliefs?

I don't think any of us knows anything really ...well, apart from the fact we are conscious! We are just cast adrift into this world. We do not know what we are, where we come from, where we are going, what the world is, and why it has the nature it has, and whether our existence has any type of meaning or purpose. We are lost in a huge chasm of unfathomable mystery, and so we just soldier on.

More on the Free Will issue

 I read the following article today.

Yes, We Have Free Will. No, We Absolutely Do Not

Sapolsky tells readers that the “biology over which you had no control, interacting with the environment over which you had no control, made you you.”

I disagree entirely. Neither genes nor an environment, nor both makes us what we are. We have an intrinsic essence.

[N]o matter how much you try, you can’t intend to intend something. You can’t will yourself to have willpower. You can’t think of what you’re going to think of next. It’s simply not possible.”

True, but irrelevant. As usual the free will deniers demand too much of free will. (BTW, this is a universal tendency in all topics, namely attacking a position that few if any people actually believe in).

Although I can’t intend to intend, I can intend. Where does that come from? It comes from my essence. An illustrative example is I can’t choose to be interested in celebrities rather than philosophical issues. Does this entail I don’t have free will? No, because my essence is of such a nature that I am more interested in philosophy. But where does my essence come from? I suggest that we determine our own natures. We self-define ourselves, as it were.

And, incidentally, this is all far removed from the idea we have no more free will than a boulder has as it rolls down a hill, or the moon has as it orbits the Earth. We are, in the most immediate sense, implicitly aware of our own causal agency. It requires an effort on our parts to get out of bed in the morning, the laws of nature by themselves do not suffice.

The way Sapolsky sees it, you can’t escape the biological and cultural forces and environmental factors that preceded you and shaped you. “There’s not a crack anywhere in there to shoehorn in free will,” he said. “When you look at every contemporary argument for free will that’s not invoking God or fairy dust or something, at some point, one must assume a step that bypasses the antecedent causes. But that violates the laws of how neurons work, atoms work, and universes work. Your life is nothing but that: everything that came before.”

This reference to God or fairy dust is another way of saying that he thinks that naturalism or materialism is true and there are only physical forces. The same typical pattern where materialists accuse their opponent of appealing to magic or the supernatural. It’s a technique to try and convince the reader not by arguments, but by utilizing people's aversion to supernatural or magical explanations, even though it is an incorrect employment of those words.

Essentially, here he's appealing to the notion that the world is physical closed, e.g. that physical causes account for absolutely all change in the world. But appealing to such physical causal closure is transparent question begging.


My first ever computer

It's just about exactly 25 years that I got my first ever computer. From a place called "Time" (it no longer exists). 10Gb hard drive and had Windows 98 2nd edition on it.  I didn't have a scooby how to do anything on it.  But I managed to work out how to play Tomb Raider 2 (I'd already played Tomb Raider 1 on a PlayStation 1 that I had borrowed). Never went on the internet till about 3 months later in 1999. 


Wednesday, 6 September 2023

The tragicomedy of Trussonomics

I just read this article:

Going for broke: the tragicomedy of Trussonomics 

 She was not a numbers person, she knew what the country needed.

The whole problem was that she was stupid. But why did Tory party members vote for her? Why did the Tory supporting newspapers hail the "mini" budget as outstanding and just what Britain needed?  I think it's endemic stupidity. The problem is that the mechanism whereby people get into positions of influence and power doesn't appear to pay much heed to people's actually ability or intelligence.  Influence and power is won by people being firm, being unwavering, in their convictions. Contrariwise, having a head for figures, having a nuanced stance on issues, doesn't win any favours with the masses, and it is the approval of the masses that precipitates a person's popularity and hence influence.

Monday, 21 August 2023

Astonishing Physics Facts

 































People keep currently posting above in Facebook saying essentially, wow, isn't physics amazing.

1. And apparently we never ever see anything "now". Even when talking to someone just in front of you, they're appearing as they were an incredibly small fraction of a second ago. So, in a sense, everything we ever see is non-existent if the past doesn't exist. But I think people always take the scientific story too seriously. Perhaps we should re-consider what is meant by "now"? Perhaps "now" should be defined by what the speed of light conveys. So we're not seeing a star 100 light years away as it was 100 years ago, but rather "now".

2. So at the singularity (the centre) of a black hole, in a split second the whole of eternity flashes by in the rest of the Universe. Or perhaps Einstein's equations break down in such extreme conditions! 

3. Refers to dark matter. Translation -- the galaxies exhibit motions not currently accommodated by our current understanding of gravity. Or, in other words, our theories in physics don't currently describe everything. But putting it this way is less likely to exhibit the wow! from people...

4 & 5. Takes our theories in physics as depicting a literal state of affairs. Ignores underdetermination of theories that suggest physics is merely engaged in describing the world via mathematical equations, not saying what its ultimate nature is.

6. What is amazing is that reality exhibits patterns that we can mathematically describe. But 6 seems to suggest that gravity is a real thing with causal powers, which like 4 and 5, is a metaphysical interpretation.

7. Meaningless blather, but sounds cool to say it. 

8. Or observation (as in a perceptual experience) defines reality.

Saturday, 8 July 2023

Brains create consciousness?

All aspects of consciousness -- whether pains, perceptual experiences, thoughts and so on -- can be changed, attenuated, modulated, even stopped altogether by the brain. Those who are skeptical of the existence of a soul make great play of this and appear to think this presents almost incontrovertible evidence that the brain entirely creates all of our conscious experiences – a soul is not required. For them, the ability of the brain to change our conscious states implies that the brain must create them.

Let’s think about this for a minute. Let's imagine that I can see a tree in front of me. How is this possible? Well, the tree has to exist, my eyes need to be functioning, and the appropriate regions of my brain need to be functioning correctly. Considering how incredibly complex my brain is, this makes for an intricate causal chain. Yet, for all that, I can stop my vision of the tree, delete my vision, by the simple expedient of closing my eyes. Or my vision of the tree could be compromised or even blocked if I were wearing a pair of eyeglasses and the lenses were fogged up. But I then clean them, and once again I have 20/20 vision. But this act of cleaning the lenses played no role in creating my vision. Indeed, it would be preposterous to suppose it could. The bottom line is the process by which we are able to visually see is a complex involved one, but that very simple acts or procedures can block or attenuate our vision. And reversing those very simple acts or procedures can restore our vision again. But it would be very naive to suppose that these acts and procedures play any role in the actual creation of our vision.

But, I think it's very possible that precisely this naive mistake is being made when it comes to the brain. I have argued at various places elsewhere -- for example, part 2 of my Brains affecting Minds do not rule out an Afterlife -- that we face arguably irreconcilable difficulties in supposing the brain actually creates consciousness. And even if that were not so, presumably it would be an extraordinarily convoluted and complex process. Why not, therefore, prefer the far more feasible and relatively unproblematic hypothesis that the self and its conscious states are not created by the brain at all? That the brain, instead, merely changes, modulates, and attenuates this pre-existing self with its conscious states?

Thursday, 8 June 2023

A Chick Repellent

 


He's being sarcastic. I often get told by guys that it's "a chick repellent" or words to that effect. These people are typically boorish individuals whose conversations are frequently focussed on having sex with women, fighting, and other topics that do not interest me. They also invariably have a deep antipathy towards me, and the feeling is entirely mutual.

I used to think they were talking absolute nonsense.  But I have found out that they are correct. My other blog covers philosophical issues, and people consider it to be quite intellectual. Literally, around 60-70% of the time when I linked to my blog on a dating site, the woman concerned simply stopped communicating with me. This baffled me, as I thought it would generally impress them, and they would be more interested in thoughtful men. But one of them explained that with her previous boyfriend she felt left out as she couldn't understand what her boyfriend and his friends were talking about, so she's not repeating that mistake.

I never talk about intellectual stuff in real life anyway, it's purely reserved for my blog!

Also see my Advice on getting a girlfriend.

Tuesday, 16 May 2023

The absurdity of mind as machine

I've just read this article:

The absurdity of mind as machine
 
(Note: Readers might not be able to access the article, in which case go here instead.) 

The author David Bentley Hart I personally don't always find easy to follow, he needs to make his ideas easier to understand. But what he says in this essay is excellent. He says:
[C]onsciousness, uniquely, is not a third-person phenomenon available to objective description; it is first-person all the way down. And yet it is an indispensable prejudice of the modern method that a verifiable scientific description must be an entirely third-person narrative of structural and causal connections and correspondences. On principle, it is precisely the first-person perspective that must be subdued, and even ideally banished from our investigations, in order for a properly “scientific” account to emerge from observation and experiment and theory. Any remainder of the pure subjective constitutes only an area of unintelligibility. And this, needless to say, becomes a fairly intractable difficulty when the phenomenon under investigation happens to be subjectivity as such. The problem is one not merely of appropriate scientific technique, but one of logic.
He’s saying we only know consciousness from within. But science can only ever deal with what we can observe, measure and quantify. So any attempt to make our consciousness fit in with science cannot in principle be achieved. And I agree.
For a truly scientific view of reality, it came to be believed, everything—even mind—must be reducible to one and the same mechanics of motion.
Hence, we have an impasse. Many people believe that due to the astonishing success of science and the technology it has spawned, that it must provide a complete description of reality, including consciousness. But, it cannot in principle explain consciousness, at least not while science deals only with the measurable quantifiable aspects of reality.

But nevertheless, this impossibility is ignored by academics, they are convinced we are machines. But as Bentley points out:
Yet machines do not think; neither do they experience anything; they are composites of inert parts extrinsically organized to perform functions imposed upon them from without by beings who do think and experience things, and nothing more.
We create machines to carry out a purpose that we impose. So, unlike us, such a purpose is not intrinsic to it.

Bentley adds:
This is the special absurdity of allowing an artificial method appropriate to certain isolated questions to hypertrophy into a universal judgment on all of reality, including those of its aspects to which such a method cannot possibly apply. I have known even trained physicists, who should know better, who speak as if Laplace was correct, and that a superlatively intelligent demon who knew all the present dispositions of the atoms composing the universe could infallibly predict—from the bottom up—all future events, including my actions at this moment. But this is nonsense. To whatever degree I am a physical system, I am also an intentional “system” whose mental events take the forms of semeiotic (symbolic, interpretive) determinations, and whose actions are usually the consequences of intentions that are irreducibly teleological. As such, these intentions could appear nowhere within a reductive account of the discrete processes composing me as a physical event; final causes or intentional are not visible within any inventory of the impersonal antecedent physical events composing me. Simply said, I have reasons for acting, and act according to reasons. The obvious physicalist riposte to this, of course, is to claim that all intentionality is in some sense illusory, or reducible to complex electrochemical brain events, which are in turn reducible to molecular description, and then to atomic description, and so on. But that too is obviously false (though that argument must be deferred for now).
When I decide to get up out of bed in the morning, physical forces do not suffice. I have to intend to move my body, to make a conscious effort. Our behaviour, including everything we say, is directed towards an end. Quite unlike the impersonal alleged forces within chemistry and physics.
This is why, among devout philosophical physicalists, such wild extremes as eliminativist reductionism and the materialist version of panpsychism are ever more in vogue.
Yes, the only way to square consciousness with a complete scientific description of reality is to deny the very existence of consciousness.

Wednesday, 26 April 2023

Students using ChatGPT for their essays.

This philosophy professor has been told by her daughter that students en masse are using chatGPT for their essays.

That is not good for specifically philosophy since it's going to result in completely crap essays that don't really argue but regurgitate the standard hackneyed spiel on the topic in question.  Essays that are insipid, banal, characterless, bland and boring.  Essays that have a soporific effect.  The precise diametric opposite to my essays in my philosophy blog
. 😉

Capital Punishment and the Myth of Rational Debate

I read the following article by Jesse Bering. The Myth of Rational Debate Bering asks: Ask yourself if there are any empirical facts that wo...