It keeps being claimed (eg David Papineau, Sean Carroll et al) that if consciousness caused anything in the brain over and above physical causation, then neuroscientists would have detected it by now. I have no idea why they would think this. The initial change precipitated in the brain might only have a minute effect, but then, via physical chains of causes and effects, cascade to larger and larger effects (see the video). Since neuroscientists are materialists, they won't be looking for any such influence and our functional MRI's lack the resolution to make any assertions in this regard in any case. It's just silly nonsense that materialists constantly put out.
Note that the notion that the world is physically closed is incoherent in any case. I argue this in my other blog in my A Causal Consciousness, Free Will, and Dualism.
NB: Apart from a couple of posts where I directly quote AI to enable me to address and argue against what it says, AI has not otherwise been used in any shape or form in either this blog nor my "Philosophical Thoughts" blog.
Showing posts with label dominoes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dominoes. Show all posts
Friday, 16 July 2021
Sunday, 2 October 2016
Was the Universe caused?
Suppose we observe a chain of toppling dominoes. Which would be the best explanation for why they are all falling over?
a) The very first domino just fell over all by itself without any cause whatsoever.
b) The chain of dominoes is infinitely long so no first falling domino is required.
c) An external agent pushed the very first one over.
a) The very first domino just fell over all by itself without any cause whatsoever.
b) The chain of dominoes is infinitely long so no first falling domino is required.
c) An external agent pushed the very first one over.
"a" is to give up on a rational explanations. If the first domino falls all by itself, then why can't all the other dominoes just fall by themselves?
"b" simply leaves unanswered as to why an infinite chain of dominoes exist. It either exists without a cause -- in which case again we have to give up on a rational explanation -- or they were caused by an external agent.
Opting for "a" or "b" is to give up on providing an explanation. Only "c" is viable.
The same goes for the entire physical Universe (and no, what caused God is not a valid refutation).
"b" simply leaves unanswered as to why an infinite chain of dominoes exist. It either exists without a cause -- in which case again we have to give up on a rational explanation -- or they were caused by an external agent.
Opting for "a" or "b" is to give up on providing an explanation. Only "c" is viable.
The same goes for the entire physical Universe (and no, what caused God is not a valid refutation).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Capital Punishment and the Myth of Rational Debate
I read the following article by Jesse Bering. The Myth of Rational Debate Bering asks: Ask yourself if there are any empirical facts that wo...
-
An interesting article about thought experiments here . People do tend to ignore thought experiments. I get the strong impression that they ...
-
Someone on twitter/X asked the following question: A mathematician emerges from a cave, hands you the photo below, and asks "Will a c...
-
From here : 1. "If it’s a phenomena (and not just an event), it will or can be repeated". Depends what the author means by ...
-
I recently read the following article: What the Buddha Didn't Teach About Reincarnation It says: "This is not to say that “we” ...
-
There's 2 possibilities: a) This is the only life there is. When we die we simply cease to exist. Our lives and the Universe are, in a...
-
Someone said in a comment under a Guardian article: My solution to this problem is somewhat simplistic. I don't do social media. As in...
-
The Wikipedia page on Lucy Letby First of all, let me say at the outset that I'm really loath to comment on whether I think she's gu...
-
Woody Allen has said : I firmly believe ... that life is meaningless. I’m not alone in thinking this — there have been many great minds far...
-
According to this article Greenland is the country with the world's highest suicide rate. From 1900-1930 Greenland had a suicide rate ...
-
Below on the left is a photo of me taken back in 1985. I uploaded that photo to ChatGPT and said to it "Generate an image of what this ...